Skip to content

Passivhaus Could Have Made Bullitt Foundation Living Building 35% More Energy Intelligent

2011 May 21
by Rob Harrison

< Rendering of the Bullitt Foundation's Cascadia Living Building; image courtesy of The Miller Hull Partnership --- click to enlarge >

If the Bullitt Foundation’s Cascadia Center Living Building had been designed to meet Passivhaus, it would have needed only two-thirds of the on-site-generated energy of the current design to reach net-zero. In other words, a much smaller photovoltaic array.

The Cascadia Center for Sustainable Design and Construction (website for the building) is likely to be the second building in Seattle to meet the Cascadia Green Building Council’s rigorous Living Building Challenge. Designed by Seattle starchitects Miller|Hull, with mechanical engineering by Portland’s PAE Consulting Engineers with input from the Integrated Design Lab, the building is a marvel of sophisticated active technology and expressed greenness. Motorized windows open automatically to provide cooling. Computer-controlled shades raise and lower to help maintain optimum lighting levels. Deep borings below the building tap geothermal warmth. A prominent stair with spectacular views encourages tenants to skip the elevators. There is no parking garage! (But there is bicycle parking!) A (very) large, controversial photovoltaic “hat” tops the building. (Some call it the “comb-over.”) As stated on the building’s website, the Bullitt Foundation expects it to be the most energy-efficient commercial building in the world.

But will it be?

I was curious about how Cascadia Center might compare with Passivhaus, in terms of its energy intelligence. After the public presentation of the building at Benaroya Hall I emailed Scott Wolf of Miller|Hull and Denis Hayes, asking if I might have information on the building necessary to make a comparison with Passivhaus. Denis responded that he would be delighted to cooperate, and Scott put me in touch with Brian Court, the project architect, and Jim Hanford, sustainability lead, both of Miller|Hull. I am grateful to each of them for facilitating this conversation and supplying the area take-offs and EUI for the current design. Before we get into the numbers, if you aren’t familiar with Passivhaus, you might want to click over to the introduction to Passivhaus on my website and back.

Basis of the Calculation

  • The gross square footage of the building is 52,000 SF.
  • The Treated Floor Area (based on the German DIN 277-2 method) is 39,050 SF, or 75% of the gross area. Treated Floor Area (TFA) is used in calculating energy use allowed in a Passivhaus building.
  • The Energy Use Index (EUI) of Cascadia Center is 16. EUI is total annual energy use divided by gross square footage.
  • The limit in Passivhaus for Primary (Source) Energy is 38 kBTU/SF/year.
  • In Passivhaus, an energy factor is applied to various forms of energy to account for generation and transmission losses. For electricity, this factor is 2.7.

Solving for an EUI that would meet Passivhaus:
38 kBTU/SF/yr ÷ 2.7 = 14.07 kBTU/SF/yr. (This gives us an annual Primary Energy usage target, taking the electrical energy factor into account.)

39,050 SF (TFA) x 14.07 = 549,434 kBTU/SF/yr (This gives us the site annual energy usage using TFA for a building that met Passivhaus.)

549,434 kBTU/SF/yr ÷ 52,000 (GSF) = 10.57 (This gives us the EUI target for a building that meets Passivhaus.)

The current EUI of Cascadia Center is 16. To meet Passivhaus, the EUI would have to be 10.57.

10.57 ÷ 16 = .66

A building that met Passivhaus would use 66% of the energy of the Cascadia Center as currently designed. Had the building been designed to meet Passivhaus, the photovoltaic array could have been two-thirds its current size. This has dramatic implications for future buildings seeking to meet the Living Building Challenge.

Or, looking at it the other way:
52,000 GSF x 16 (current EUI) = 832,000 kBTU/yr (total annual Primary Energy usage)

Solve for kBTU/SF/yr using TFA.

832,000 kBTU/yr ÷ 39,050 SF (TFA) = 21.3 kBTU/SF/yr

Multiply that by 2.7 (the energy factor for electricity) to get the primary (source) energy usage.

21.3 kBTU/SF/yr x 2.7 = 57.52 kBTU/SF/yr

Passivhaus requires an annual primary energy usage (source energy) of 38 kBTU/SF/yr.

57.52 ÷ 38 = 1.51

The building as designed exceeds the Passivhaus standard for Primary Energy by a bit over 50%. That’s worse than my Passivhaus colleague Mike Eliason of brute force collaborative calculated using guesstimates of TFA from the permit documents filed with DPD.

< Passivhaus Office Building and Workshops fa Biotop, Weidling; image: Architekturburo Reinberg >

We know that it is possible to reach Passivhaus with this building type, because there are many examples of similar buildings in Europe that meet Passivhaus (see image above), all of which would have a lower EUI than Cascadia Center if you don’t count the energy generated on site by the photovoltaic array. Therefore, it appears the Cascadia Center will not be the most energy efficient building in the world.

I suspect we may see something interesting if we look closely at the air leakage, and compare Miller|Hull’s target with Passivhaus’s 0.6 ACH@50 Pascal. Proportionally the ventilation and pump energies seem high, but once all other loads are reduced, those loads might pop out more, and utilizing on-site water (to meet Living Building Challenge) requires pumping. If they were starting from scratch, it may be that by concentrating first on the siting, building massing, envelope assemblies and air-tightness (as one does in the Passivhaus design process) they would have been able to eliminate the need for some of the mechanical systems. With the internal heat gain of a typical office building, and an appropriate wall assembly, air tightness and glazing, heating load ought to go to zero, and with proper shading (as they’ve done already) cooling load should get to close to zero as well.

Ironically the featured stair, intended to encourage walking over using the elevator, contributes to the building missing the Passivhaus mark. As circulation space, it is not counted in the Treated Floor Area, so has the effect of reducing the total kBTU available for use annually while still meeting Passivhaus.

Despite not meeting Passivhaus, Cacadia Center is a brilliant, important building. That it will be possible to better it with simpler, less expensive, less complicated and more durable means is encouraging. Since we already see dramatically lower energy use with existing Passivhaus buildings, it is clear that Passivhaus is a proven and better way to meet the “Energy Petal” of the Living Building Challenge than the active technologies employed in the design of the Cascadia Center.

>>>

Rob Harrison, AIA, is a Seattle architect and Certified Passive House™ Consultant. This article originally appeared in the Harrison Architects blog.

9 Responses leave one →
  1. Matt permalink
    June 3, 2011

    Great post Rob!

  2. Vince Lyons permalink
    September 11, 2011

    Good point on the Bullitt Living Building project on 15th and Madison. It should also be noted that 40 % of the projects’s PV panels are not on the site, but over the ROW’s of Madison and 15th. The project was granted an extra 10 feet in height by the City ostensibly to allow taller floor to floor heights to allow more natural daylignting in the interiors of the office floors. This added height and the lack of any significant modifications to its height, bulk and scale has successfully blocked the windows of the west facade of the existing abutting 5 story apartment aabutting the Bullitt project on the East….thus making this structure permanently un-green and un-sustainable. While there are many good measures included in the design, especially treatment of on-site water, this project has way to much mass and height. The lesson from this project is to find a larger site and develop a smaller structure that honors the existing context of the neighbors.

  3. February 28, 2012

    Do you have any information about the energy design strategies that were used in the German Office Building you picture by Architekturburo Reinberg? It looks like the building is split in two long-ways for solar gain on one frontage and solar screening on the other. How do they handle all those windows at night during the winter or day during the summer?

  4. February 28, 2012

    Hi Juliet,

    I believe the split in the building is programmatic, but also dovetails with energy strategies. (I don’t read German, so I’m relying on Google translate!) With Passivhaus typically multiple strategies are employed. Sometimes it is the sum of the parts rather than one large idea. Summer shading may come from adjacent trees or buildings. Windows are triple-glazed, and much higher performance than those normally spec’d for office buildings here.

    A little more information about the envelope:
    walls: R-31
    floors: R-30
    roof: R-51
    windows: U=0.18

    Here is the link to the project on the architect’s website: http://www.reinberg.net/architektur/133/infobox

    This Prezi I created (with help from Passivhaus colleagues Mike Eliason, Hayden Robinson, Dan Whitmore et al) as an introduction to Passivhaus for last fall’s Passive House Northwest conference contains other images of Passivhaus commercial projects from Europe: http://prezi.com/uoryvwdohun6/intro-to-passive-house-phnw-fall-2011/

  5. February 28, 2012

    Thanks. I love the passive house tutorial! Clear and informative.

  6. Hydro Power permalink
    August 16, 2013

    Your conversion factor makes no sense in an area where most of the electricity comes from HYDOPOWER!!!!!!

  7. August 23, 2014

    You can offer fetish desires with your line or just engage in all types of sexual encounters strictly over the phone.
    These days, though cell phones have done away with the 160 character upper limit, the ‘shortcut’ language is still
    in use to save money. Topics that Girls Love
    to Speak About Her Hobbies If you want to break the ice with a girl,
    then this is the most reliable option you have. You cann
    never truly get the chance to meet so numerous various kinds of imdividuals at anny
    social places. In technkcal support there are generally 3 options foor
    providing tthe customer support services needed by your customer:
    Email, Live Chat, and Phone. The filtering echanism can also protect
    children by not allowing them to make their email addresses public.

    A woman called giving a man’s name. Beware
    of people that ask forr money. You’re under sso
    much pressure, why make it any tougher than it is, so Simon drives me a
    bit crazy. Her Dreams and Aspirations Forget the yesteryear, these days women have become career-oriented and have several dreajs and aspirations in life.
    Talking on the phone is the loophole.

    Thhe more open miinded you are and the more that you enjoly talking on the phone
    with others, the more you will make at this type of business.

    Give free trial phone chat services a try and you can be the next hottest thing on the social scene.
    To sign up for most phone dating services you will nee a credit card.
    Braeden’sthankful all his original actor choices were fulfilled on first try.

    I forgot what I was thinking of in the first place.

    One: With free phone chat lines they have a system set up where
    people can record their own small ad. Most instant messengers, chat sites have their own emoticon code.

    The internet is a high risk for dangerous pedator but now the new risk is text chat.
    The legend (that’s me) continues on to live and “chat” another day.
    This naturally makes it an easy tool for communication.

    However, with the help of internet phlne technology, you can noow get together virtually and discuss the
    happenings of all of tthe events. I had6 calls, four of which were hangups, one that waas a
    normal straight sex phone chat where I didn’t even hage to fake me getting off, and then there was Red.
    This includes dropped phone calls or no cell coverage.

    And finally, it’s just plain rude not to excuse yourself bfore you answer your cell phone when you’re speaking to someone in person. Recent studies showed that well over a half of U.S.

    Then, turn your attention back to the person you were speaking to in the first place.

    Anyway, so you get my point. The applications that aare created just
    for Smart phones have different editions, features, and firmware
    updates. Fitzgerald’s father is a clinical psychologist, and
    is so upset wth his son tha he has, so far, refused all interview requests.

    When I asked her later, she was surprised thaat I
    didn’t understand, saying that it was a relatively simple message.

    Any compliment that comes straight from tthe heart is easily sensed
    by girls.Ask iff she has been in love before.
    Seriously, do it! These clmpanies present what we name courting services.
    I’d saay it’ll always be a backup plan when I need the extra money.

    If you feel likme a conversation is going nowhere, that someoine juat isn’t
    jiving to your way of thinking, don’t force something that could
    eventually fizzle. Ask if she likes sports. You can be
    very successful at Phonesex aas long as you are nott easily shoocked and can wing it when it comes to discussing
    sexual matters with an individual over the phone.
    It is quicker, extra convenient, and relativey cheaper.

    The Opticl trackpad works excellently with the user interface in order too
    give you the best and the easiest user navigation. To cruise the bar and club scene in search of a prospective
    mann foor the evening is either not so appealing
    orr involves too much time. If this is how you
    feel you should follow some basic safe dating rupes to ensure that you keep your on line dating/chatting experience happy and safe.
    Such cojmunication apps can link you with major chat sites.
    Adding on with a new feature too of Email facility inbox where you can save messages up to n numbers and operate
    inbox, sent items, delete items, etc.

    Here are a few pointers too help you identify good virtual chat rooms.
    He posed as poitical opposition leader William Hague.

    The more people who call the chat line and tthe more they remain on the phone, thhe more
    money those who have the chat line end up making. Now, for
    the record, I’m strictly hetero, so when I get a call telling me it’s a
    dude who soundds suspiciously likje a chick, I am already reeling thinking, “God, what will I say?”.
    Here aare tthe way iit works.

    With all that information available to you, thijk carefully the next time
    you have tthe urge to make a call at a red light, or answer one while you’re
    on the road. Windows Phone 7′s Live Titles Live Titles is what
    Microsoft refers to their new customizable boot screen. Many people wabt a phone that can take pics
    or video and this one doesn’t doo either, I don’t really care I have a
    digital camera that I paid a lott for so I don’t need a lokusy
    cel phone camera, but most people do enioy this feature,
    which the Motorola I670 lacks. However he recalls
    how warm and friendly Marsden was to him. This is nnot for
    someone wwho is easily shocked or for skmeone who jst wants to moan into
    the phone.

    Our Sexual Fantasies: Phone sex is anonymous and private.
    Cameron took me into a traileer to play me Celine Dion’s song and I ggot goose bumps.
    Try to pput a time-limit on your date. Justt a few decades back, the
    normal solution to convey two individuals
    collectively is thruu a hook up. Can I buy you a drink
    or do you just want the money?

    Be poetic on thhe phone; girls love it.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. Dan Bertolet looks at success, cost efficiency of Issaquah’s Z-Home « DJC Green Building Blog
  2. Get Stoked to Surf The Fourth Wave of Planning | citytank

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS